I wanted to comment briefly on “Forgiving Dr. Mengele”. Eva Kor, I believe her name was, said repeatedly that her main goal was to release not her memory of the events in her mind, but in her body, and her emotions. Well, she didn’t say it quite like that, but that was my reading into it. She wanted to seize power, to control who she was and how she felt every day.
And she was contrasted explicitly with other women who went through what she did, and who seemingly felt the lifelong misery they were enduring to be a form of faithfulness to the memory of those who were lost.
In my own view, this goes deeper, to a sense of a need to be faithful to who you have become, to who you “are”, and if that person suffers daily from traumatic memories, from chronic and spasmodic terrors, from wincing in remembrance, from nightmares, and hypervigilence, then continuity requires us to hold on to those things.
There is fear. This is a normal and healthy thing. It keeps us safe. It tells us something isn’t right, or that an unusual degree of care and attention is needed.
Then there is the fear of fear, which for the traumatized is a quick falling off a cliff into a repetition of a sense of utter horror and helplessness. Small fears set off the whole cascade. You get triggered, and rightfully fear getting triggered, so you become smaller as a human being. You avoid anything which might set off the chain reaction.
[I will note that as someone who has a lot of trauma in him, I get the fear of being triggered. But I do not try and pretend that the world owes me a duty, or that I can live anything even approximating a good life when I attach my own mental health to the compliance of others, who for their part are very likely to be codependent enablers, and thus people who benefit psychologically from my dysfunction, fear and pain. Fuck those people. I got this.]
Then finally there is the fear of the LOSS of fear, of a moment when you realize that something that just happened would have triggered you in the past, but now doesn’t. That you are “healed”, or at least non-symptomatic, and this feels unfamiliar and strange.
Sebern Fisher talks about this a fair amount in her book. Patients lose the sense of who they are, when they no longer live with chronic fear as a constant companion (which strangely enough, is the correct word). For this reason, she never tries for too much change, too rapidly. But that is a fantastic thing, is it not, when too-rapid change is a real risk, particularly when compared to the more general theme that certain traumas really can’t be healed, but merely managed?
I of course can’t speak to the experiences not just of the Holocaust, but in some respects the worst part of it (although the children were apparently fed better in better housing, when some poison or disease was not being injected into them by a psychopath), but I can’t help but feeling 1) that the dead family members would vastly prefer healing and relative forgetting; and 2) that the deeper fear is the Void, of losing all relative bearing, of not knowing any more who one is.
When you think about it, is it not ODD that a religion from 3,000 years ago, that originated in a specific land, and was oriented around specific places, would endure thousands of miles away from its home, in lands of radically different nature? Obviously, Judaism gives something to its followers that is more powerful than the price they have always paid for being different. It gives them a clear sense of self, and a powerful means of organizing their lives. It is a powerful tool for dealing with existential angst, the confusion of life, and the pain of life.
As a tool, though, religion–all religions–can also be constraints and cages. The Self is larger than any religion. The Buddhists of course speak of Anatman, or Anatta, but what they really mean is that what we call our self is really a bit ridiculous. We have understood nothing. That, in any event, is my belief.
This Eva, I think, intuited much of this. She said “I am willing to be the person who walks outside the gate, and I am going to call this process forgiveness. You call it what you want. It’s my business, not yours, my life, not yours, and I am simply trying to point out this is an option. Beyond that, stop the talking, I have a house to sell.”
My two cents.