I’ve lived in a number of big cities for long periods of time, and I’ve seen quite a bit. When I was at Berkeley I used to get hit up by panhandlers several times daily. I took to ignoring them, and if they persisted, looking them in the eye and saying NO clearly and unambiguously. It was the same people, in the same places, nearly every day. I got compassion fatigue within two days. I was broke myself.
So his woman–wife, girlfriend, who knows?–comes up and says “leave him alone, he is rude”. And I said to her “I’m not the one begging”. She gets indignant: “I’m not begging. I’m a Christian woman and I have a job. I’m a manager at Taco Bell. I have two kids back in the car.” I looked at her and said “you are begging”.
She starts walking away, and says something about my “white ass”. I tell her “I’ve never asked anyone for money in my life”, which is true. I’ve been so broke I donated blood for money twice a week for a period of time, and that is fucking broke. You get needle marks on your arms, and have to wear long sleeve shirts, and even though it seems virtually never to happen, they tell you that on rare occasions the procedure will kill you, so you get to sit there thinking about that.
She looks at me and tells me to watch my mouth or she’s going to bust it open. I tell her “classy”, finish gassing up, and leave. I’m not small, weak, or stupid, so threats like that don’t bother me.
But I understand the anger. She is in a position where she is begging. This means she has taken on the role of Victim, and once you take on that role everyone becomes either a Protector or a Villain. I of course was a villain, and we are taught to be angry with villains.
And I thought about this some more. To be response-able means that you have the ability to react to circumstances, to choose your reaction, and in fact to proactively create the circumstances you want.
To be a victim is necessarily to feel self pity, since you are helpless. If no one helps you, then you don’t get helped.
And I thought about the old way of being, where people would rather die than take assistance, would rather do anything than be reduced to the indignity of begging.
It is my understanding that in the beginning of the Orwellian “Great Society” the government hired people to canvass poor neighborhoods and convince people to take public assistance, because the resistance was so strong.
And in our modern age, it is easy to say “Just take the money”, but what is missed in this is that in the process we all become prostitutes. Anyone who places himself in a condition of dependence on another, where he cannot raise him or herself, where individual initiative is forbidden, unnecessary, or discouraged, is sacrificing their dignity, their self respect.
All the inner qualities are invisible to socialists. All the things that make life bearable are invisible. They only see things, and it is inevitable in the process that people would become things too, which is a fairly short description of the condition of slavery. We assume slaves are USED for something, like building fences. What are the slaves on this plantation used for? Electing Democrats, obviously.
And I kept at this, and it seems to me the reason unhappiness is so common in our affluent and largely peaceful society is that in the old days the societal practice of judging people who did not take care of themselves, of judging those who failed in their duties, provided, paradoxically, a sort of comfort. Everyone was subjected to the same standard, which meant that no matter how severe your penury, there were people around you sharing it with the same dignity, the same necessary acceptance.
Society was organized so as to reject self pity. It was organized around the idea that life is tough, and we all need to be tough too.
This seems harsh, but if everyone accepts it, they avoid the burden of self pity. Do you not think poor kids in the ghettos of New York had more self respect in 1900 than they do today?
Virtually the entire program of the socialists–and I am conflating them here with the Democrats–is oriented around stoking resentment, stoking self pity, stoking self righteous anger, and using those energies to get and keep power.
This woman was a racist. There was no need to invoke race. But she doubt sees that white people in general are more successful, and has been taught to believe her decisions, how she chooses to live her life, plays little role in her outcome. She is helpless.
And ponder the recklessness which would land her in a supermarket parking lot with two kids, begging.
Do I think she donates blood? No. Do I think she works two jobs? No. I at one point was working three jobs. I have been unemployed one month in my entire adult life, and that was because I got laid off immediately before Christmas, and nobody is hiring between Dec. 23 and Jan. 2. I had a new job by Jan. 15th.
Most of the time, what appears to be the case is in fact the case. What I was seeing is that she assumes white people have money and they should be sharing it with her, since she is only asking for $4. She likely spent her money on cigarettes or lottery tickets, and begging to fill her tank with gas was part of a plan she has executed many times.
Being too compassionate is a kind of cruelty, because it enables people to live lives filled with resentment, unfilled potential, and self loathing they mask with chronic outward-directed anger. None of us need to feed this.
And I think far too many people think that exercising their right to demand boundaries, to demand respect, is cold and wrong.
The truth is you help no one by not being yourself, and you can’t be yourself if you think you have no rights, cannot make demands on others, cannot judge others, and have to be nice in all times and places. Bullshit.
It may be that this woman is still mad at me. It may also be that hearing the word “begging” caused a bit of introspection. That was certainly my intention.